Lessons from SEO Spam

Let's start with a scenario I’m sure you're familiar with: You open your web browser and go to Google to search for a product you’re planning to buy to verify its quality. You search for product reviews to compare, and the results seem promising based on Gemini’s summary and the links Google provides you. However, it's only when you begin to open the cited sources and links that you discover a wealth of low-quality web pages, which seem to be designed to bring you back to the product’s purchase page. Unchecked SEO spam has been plaguing Google for years, and it is showing no signs of stopping. Let’s unpack how businesses can ethically utilize SEO spam tactics.

A person holds a cell phone. Google search is shown on the phone's screen.

Photo by Terrillo Walls via Unsplash

what is SEO Spam?

SEO is how search engines discover your content and surface it to users who want to interact with your website. It can be quantitatively measured based on how a website ranks in search results based on a user's query. Google has published helpful resources that break down how URL and directory names, content quality, and links all contribute to how your website appears in search. These insights from Google are only the tip of the iceberg when it comes to breaking down SEO strategies, with many companies, such as SmartSites, Intero Digital, and SEOBrand, offering far more complex insights and expertise to businesses for an annual fee.

SEO spam has been a primary concern for many businesses as it can impact online sales, marketing efforts, and brand discovery. Research out of Germany points to “Review Farms” being a major culprit of SEO spam. These sites, which collect thousands of product reviews for a wide range of categories, earn money through affiliate links. Some of these sites utilize payment for positive reviews or generate their content with A.I. Webpages for “Review Farms” frequently appear and disappear from search results, indicating that search engines are monitoring these well-optimized, content-heavy sites and penalizing them in search results. These rank changes aligned perfectly with updates to Google’s search engine. This indicates that Google is aware of overabundance, and the company is trying to keep up the battle against “Review Farms” with each iteration its search algorithm.

In recent years, changes to Google’s search index have radically changed how SEO can be taken advantage of. By using strategies, such as affiliate links and content descriptions, anyone can improve their website’s ranking in search engines by posting on a user-generated forum to boost SEO. This created the perfect storm for SEO spam to be pushed out to consumers via search engines, and even now, as A.I. search results become commonplace, SEO spam has adapted.

A website performance dashboard showing total clicks, total impressions, average CTR, and average position. There is a line graph showing data from 2/24/19 to 6/2/19.

Photo by Stephen Phillips via Unsplash

How to Compete with SEO Spam

SEO spam minimizes the work of thoughtful website design and prioritizes fraudulent strategies to boost content in search engine rankings. However, by understanding how SEO spam is dramatically affecting search rankings, we can learn a great deal from it. By fairly and thoughtfully implementing the following strategies that scammers are taking advantage of, your business can boost its website’s SEO while beating out any potential spam that may be getting in the way of users finding your content.

  1. Support customer reviews and engagement online

With user-generated content seen well in the eyes of search engines, prompting your customers to leave reviews online is essential. By receiving genuine, original posts on Reddit, LinkedIn, or personal blogs, you can ethically compete with spam reviews. If you believe in what you do and offer a quality experience, promoting your business through digital word of mouth can increase your customer base.

2. Create a blog

Blog and review content does well, especially in the eyes of GEO (the A.I. summary equivalent of SEO) and gives your website the opportunity to provide the quality content that search engines prioritize. SEO spam lags in relevancy of the article’s title to the content, and complexity of the writing. To combat this and gain an edge, ensure that your content and headline is answering a searchable question and is informative, while maintaining useful content structures, such as headlines, improve readability for both site visitors and search engines.

3. Utilize partnership work for ‘affiliate marketing’ purposes

If your organization is partnering with another company, ensure you provide them with relevant links to your website to include in any press releases or articles they may share about your partnership. Google has indicated that linking to indexed websites optimizes search rankings. so mutually benefiting from the awareness that collaborations can provide is a great tool at your disposal. 

4. Back up your writing

Creating a sense of trust and authority is something that SEO spam can’t compete with. Google emphasizes that the EEAT (experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness) principles are crucial. EEAT creates staying power by building your site’s credibility. You will want to ensure that your content’s sources are cited and linked to, authors have bios, and any research has documented results.

By understanding the impacts of SEO spam tactics, organizations can know why search engine algorithms sometimes reward at the cost of user experience. The opportunity now for companies to be aware of how SEO is being abused, and reclaim it with integrity. In doing so, our websites don’t just compete with spam, they outlast it.